Court Farm Garden Centre in Tolworth is set to be demolished to make way for a large retail store, even though no one yet knows who will run it.

Kingston Road Kingston Bypass Jubilee Way Alpine Avenue Hazel Bank Hamilton Avenue Tolworth (National Rail)Tolworth Court Farm, Old Kingston Road, Riverhill, Tolworth, Royal Borough of Kingston upon Thames, Greater London, England, KT4 7QH, United KingdomCourt Farm Garden Centre KINGSTON UPON THAMES 100 m© OpenStreetMap contributors · Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right
© OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the ODbL · Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right

Kingston Council’s Planning Committee gave outline approval on 11 November 2026 for a store of up to 2,400 sq m on the site in Old Kingston Road. The plans went ahead despite concerns over traffic, air quality and building on protected open land.

The applicant’s agent, James Isles, said there was market interest in the site, “especially from discount convenience food store operators, but no contract is in place as yet”. He said operators wanted to see outline permission before committing. The officers’ report says the store “would likely be a food store”, and the traffic assessment was carried out on that basis.

The plans also include 91 sq m of replacement office space for a neighbouring landscaping business, which employs seven people, and improvements to the access road, including a new cycleway and footpath.

Proposed site layout plan for Court Farm Garden Centre redevelopment, showing indicative store footprint and parking.
Proposed site layout plan for Court Farm Garden Centre redevelopment, showing indicative store footprint and parking.Source: Planning Committee papers, 11 November 2026

Because this is an outline application, the committee approved the access and layout, including the position of buildings and the number of parking spaces. The store’s appearance, scale and landscaping will be decided later through “reserved matters” applications.

The application was a resubmission of plans refused in June 2025. The new application dealt with several technical issues behind that refusal. These included the lack of a sequential test, which checks whether shops built outside town centres could go on more central sites instead, as well as transport concerns and environmental issues.

‘We haven’t a clue’

The committee approved the plans by nine votes to one. Councillor Ian George voted against, and there were no abstentions.

Several councillors who backed the scheme voiced doubts. Councillor Stephen Evans supported it with what he called “healthy scepticism”. “We’re in the odd position where we find ourselves really obliged to move towards granting outline planning permission when we’re not quite sure what’s going to be built there,” he said. “We haven’t a clue who’s actually going to operate whatever’s going to be built there. We don’t even know whether it’s needed.”

Councillor Ian Manders warned that “speculative development… does not mean an actual development at the end of it. And certainly not a viable development.”

Councillor Roger Hayes questioned why the process tested whether the store could go elsewhere, but not whether it was needed at all, given it is “out of town, away from the district centre, and in metropolitan open land”. He voted in favour.

To guard against the site lying empty, the committee cut the deadline for submitting reserved matters applications from the usual three years to two. Development must then start within two years of the last reserved matter being approved. Cllr Manders said the aim was “to stop blight on the site”, so that existing businesses would not be cleared out only for the land to become derelict.

Site plan showing the area outlined in red for the proposed redevelopment of Court Farm Garden Centre.
Site plan showing the area outlined in red for the proposed redevelopment of Court Farm Garden Centre.Source: Planning Committee papers, 11 November 2026

Protected land

The site is designated Metropolitan Open Land (MOL), which is given similar protection to Green Belt. However, it is classed as previously developed land. Under national planning policy, it can be redeveloped if the scheme would not cause substantial harm to the land’s openness.

Officers accepted there would be “some limited harm” but concluded it was not substantial, and the Greater London Authority (GLA) agreed. Cllr George disagreed: “The officers are the experts, obviously. And they don’t think it’s substantial harm. I do.”

Objections

One member of the public, Bridget Walker, objected, along with the Kingston upon Thames Society. The applicant also consulted immediate neighbours in Old Kingston Road and received four responses.

Ms Walker told the committee that turning the garden centre into a superstore with access onto the busy Kingston Road “will cause further traffic hold-ups in the area”. She also said the lack of a fire strategy had been a reason for refusal last time, and that the new application still had none.

Planning officers said a full fire strategy would be premature at the outline stage, because the building’s final design, size and materials are not yet known. However, the applicant is widening the access road and has provided a diagram showing that a fire engine can get in and out. Mr Murray said a fire strategy will be required by condition and assessed alongside the detailed design at the reserved matters stage.

The Kingston upon Thames Society objected on the grounds of a “significant adverse impact on the open character” of the MOL. It also warned of a likely impact on the retail viability of Tolworth town centre, and said the proposed vehicle access posed significant challenges for traffic.

Parking, traffic and air quality

The store will have 75 parking spaces, the same as the garden centre. That exceeds the London Plan maximum of 48. Officers noted the conflict with policy, but said it was reduced by plans to charge for parking. Planning officer John Murray said there will be a flat fee of £2.50 and a maximum stay of 90 minutes, with the fee refunded for customers who spend more than £20.

Transport for London (TfL) and the council’s traffic engineers did not object to the access arrangements, subject to safeguards secured through a Section 106 agreement. These include highway works and a travel plan backed by a £50,000 bond. If the store adds 30 seconds or more to journey times on the K2 bus route, the applicant will have to pay up to £400,000 a year for five years towards bus services.

The council’s pollution control officer raised concerns that the air quality assessment had wrongly classed the store as a convenience store rather than a superstore. Ms Walker said the store is almost 10 times larger than the convenience store category allows.

The approval depends on an updated assessment that meets the “air quality neutral” benchmark. If that is not possible, financial contributions will be secured through the Section 106 agreement. If the updated assessment complies with policy, officers will issue the decision in consultation with the committee chair. If it does not, Mr Murray said, the application will come back to the committee.

Jobs and green improvements

Mr Isles said the store is expected to create around 40 full-time equivalent jobs, compared with about 32 on the site now, including existing tenants. The officers’ report says final staffing levels have yet to be confirmed.

The scheme is projected to deliver a biodiversity net gain of more than 10%, with the ecological improvements set out in a Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan (HMMP). The plan will include key performance indicators and a way to put things right if targets are missed. The scheme is also expected to improve drainage, reduce surface water run-off, and add new cycle lanes and walkways.

The approval is also subject to a legal agreement and a series of conditions. Detailed landscaping, fire safety measures, and energy and sustainability strategies must be submitted with the reserved matters applications.

No further referral to the Mayor of London is needed.