The former East Barnet Library is set to be demolished and replaced with up to 20 social rent homes, after Barnet Council’s cabinet cleared the way for the scheme.

East Barnet Road Cat Hill Longmore Avenue York Road Crescent Road St Wilfrid's Road New Barnet (National Rail)New Barnet Brookhill Road, Oakleigh Park, East Barnet, London Borough of Barnet, Greater London, England, EN4 8SL, United KingdomEast Barnet Library Site BARNET 100 m© OpenStreetMap contributors · Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right
© OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the ODbL · Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right

At a meeting on Tuesday 17 November 2026, the cabinet approved the “appropriation” of the site at 85 Brookhill Road, a legal step that changes the purpose for which the council holds the land. The library has moved to New Barnet, where it now shares a building with the leisure centre.

The appropriation means that, once planning permission is granted, the council can use powers under the Housing and Planning Act 2016 to override third parties’ legal rights over the land, such as rights of way or restrictive covenants, that could otherwise delay or block the development. Anyone whose rights are affected would be entitled to compensation from the council instead of being able to stop the scheme. The council says the public benefit of the new homes justifies this.

‘Rabbit hutches’

The design and mix of homes have still to be finalised. Opposition Conservative councillor Jennifer Grocock said the proposals were for 13 to 14 homes, mostly one- and two-bedroom flats with a few three-bedroom flats. The council’s report says the site is expected to deliver up to 20.

“East Barnet residents will not tolerate that,” Cllr Grocock said. “They want family homes in the area. They want three and four-bedroom homes.” She warned there would likely be protests. “The public absolutely hate rabbit hutches.”

Cllr Ross Houston, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Homes and Regeneration, said the council would try to include as many family homes as possible, but acknowledged the economic challenges facing development in London.

Charity must move

The building is currently used on a temporary basis by the Young Barnet Foundation, a local charity supporting activities and opportunities for children and young people across the borough. The report says this was always meant to be an interim arrangement.

If planning permission is granted, the charity will have to leave so that building work can start by March 2027 at the latest. Meeting that deadline is critical to keeping the scheme eligible for Greater London Authority funding from its Affordable Homes Programme. The council says it is working with the charity to find somewhere else to go, ideally a long-term home.

“In order to secure a grant for this, we need to be on site by next year,” Cllr Houston said.

Built in a factory

The site is one of four in the council’s Small Sites Modular Programme, which is expected to deliver about 30 to 40 social rent homes in total. The others are Nightingale Nursery in Victoria Road, Whetstone Close and Reets Farm Close. The modular housing company Zed Pods was chosen to build them after a tender, and the contract was awarded in June 2026.

Cllr Houston said modular construction, where most of each home is built in a factory, would ensure high-quality building, be better for the environment and cause less disruption for neighbours. The report says more than 60% of the construction will take place off site. The homes will have an energy rating of at least A, and will be net zero carbon for regulated energy use, with air source heat pumps and solar panels. They are expected to perform to the same overall standard as Passivhaus homes.

Zed Pods is consulting the public, and a planning application is expected later this year.

The appropriation is temporary. Once the homes are built, a further report will go to the cabinet to move the land into the council’s Housing Revenue Account, the ring-fenced account for council housing, so the homes can be managed as social housing.

Councillor Peter Zinkin criticised how hard it was to follow the project’s history, which dates back to 2021. “I do not understand how any resident could possibly understand where this project was or where it would come from, based on being told that there are three background papers, the main one of which was more than five years ago,” he said.

An officer said the project had already been through the council’s approval process and its budget had been allocated. The report does not set out the scheme’s cost.