Cutting Lewisham’s road and pavement repair budget could end up costing more than it saves, councillors have warned.

The council plans to save £375,000 on highways maintenance in 2027/28. The saving is made up of £200,000 from repairs to roads and pavements, £75,000 from cleaning gullies and drains, and a £100,000 recharge reflecting service costs.

That is a 17% cut to the £2.2m highways maintenance budget. The maintenance budget is part of a £4.7m day-to-day budget for highways and transport, and the service also has a £2.5m capital budget for longer-term investment.

Steve Everson, Executive Director for Place, described it as “a relatively modest reduction” in the context of the council’s wider budget position. The council said that because the borough has a “green” overall rating in the Department for Transport’s road maintenance ratings, the cuts could be managed with little immediate impact. Main roads will continue to be maintained as usual.

‘Find the savings elsewhere’

The Sustainable Development Select Committee asked for analysis of why savings were expected and how they would be monitored. Members were concerned that cutting planned maintenance might not save money at all. As roads and pavements deteriorate, costs could rise through more emergency repairs, insurance claims and emergency call-outs. If they deteriorate badly, extra investment could be needed later to bring them back to an acceptable standard.

When the Overview and Scrutiny Committee considered the officers’ response on Wednesday 18 November, its chair, Councillor Robin McGhee, said it fell short.

“My view is that it doesn’t satisfactorily explain why savings are anticipated, because it doesn’t demonstrate that cuts that are made to proactive roads management will actually lead to longer-term savings,” he said. “Of course, if roads and pavements deteriorate, that would lead to longer-term costs.”

He added: “My preference would be that we make a recommendation that the savings are found elsewhere.”

The committee stopped short of a formal recommendation. Instead, it said it was “concerned about this proposal and that Mayor and Cabinet should consider it carefully”. Mayor and Cabinet is due to make a final decision on 2 December.

An officer acknowledged that reducing maintenance could mean more money is needed in future.

The council will monitor the roads through regular condition surveys and inspections, and will carry out repairs where defects pose a safety risk. Mr Everson said the council also looked at accident reports and “reports that come in from residents if they’re concerned about the quality of our asset”.

The council will check the impact of the savings on residents every month for the first six months, then every quarter. It will also watch for any serious deterioration that could create future costs, and consider whether extra investment is needed in later years.