City of London residents will continue to receive free garden waste collections, a decision made by the Port Health & Environmental Services Committee despite a trial revealing extremely low uptake.

The committee has opted against introducing fees, choosing instead to maintain the service as free of charge, a move supported by the fact that the income generated from imposing a service charge would be minimal.

Low Demand and Limited Gardens

The six-month trial, which began in April 2026, saw only seven garden waste collections completed from five residential properties, collecting a total of 135.7kg of material. This low demand was observed despite efforts to promote the service through various channels, including resident newsletters, social media, and the City of London website. While the report does not explicitly state the specific reasons for this low uptake, it is noted that there are very few gardens in the City of London. One committee member stated that the garden waste they most often throw away is flowers.

Service Integration and Cost-Effectiveness

The trial successfully demonstrated that garden waste collections could be effectively managed using existing bulky waste collection infrastructure. Veolia has the capacity to incorporate this into the current service due to low participation and minimal waste quantities, meaning no additional resources are required. Disposal also does not have a significant cost implication due to the minimal tonnages collected. The potential future cost for purchasing garden waste bags is estimated at £130.00 per 1000 bags if free surplus stock becomes unavailable.

Options Considered and Legal Obligation

Three charging models were presented to the committee: continuing the service free of charge, a pay-as-you-go model at £5 per collection, and an annual subscription of £70 per household. Officers recommended continuing the service free of charge, arguing that it maximises accessibility and encourages participation without incurring additional costs. The service is provided in compliance with the Simpler Recycling legislation, introduced as part of the Environment Act 2021, which mandates local authorities to offer separate garden waste collections. While the legislation permits charging for this service, the City of London has opted to keep it free. Benchmarking shows that charging arrangements vary between local authorities, with Westminster, Greenwich, and Tower Hamlets currently providing garden waste collections free of charge, while others operate annual subscription-based models ranging from £79-£99.

Collection Process and Future Review

Residents obtained garden waste sacks from their local library or estate office, and collections were arranged through the existing bulky waste booking process. The collected waste is weighed, then taken from Walbrook Wharf with wider Parks and Gardens green waste to the transfer station. The committee will receive an annual update on the service's usage as part of the fees and charges report. This will allow for a review of the service and any potential cost implications should demand significantly increase, although the service can be incorporated into current service provisions without placing additional pressures on revenue budgets.