City of London drivers show high compliance with engine idling rules, with few penalties issued.
The City of London has seen a high rate of compliance among drivers regarding unnecessary engine idling, with enforcement data revealing that a vast majority of observed vehicles had their engines switched off. Over a six-month period in 2026, out of 3,700 observations, only 21 warning notices and three Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) were issued.
This data was presented to the Port Health & Environmental Services Committee, highlighting the effectiveness of the City Corporation's approach, which combines proactive engagement with enforcement powers. Civil Enforcement Officers (CEOs) can issue PCNs of £160 (reduced to £80 if paid within 14 days) for idling engines, but the low number of penalties suggests that driver engagement is the primary driver of compliance.
Proactive Measures
The City Corporation employs a range of strategies to discourage engine idling, including officers speaking directly to drivers, erecting signs in 'hotspot' areas, and incorporating a 'no vehicle idling' policy into City Corporation contracts. They also liaise with construction companies to ensure vehicles waiting to access sites switch off their engines, a requirement now included in the City Code of Practice for Construction and Deconstruction.
Intelligence-led patrols, the addition of an engine idling reporting facility to the 'Report A Problem' app, and letters sent to companies whose drivers are found idling also form part of the proactive approach. The City Corporation also participates in a London-wide idling action programme funded by the Mayor of London, which is currently seeking funding for continuation.
Enforcement and Engagement
A City-wide Traffic Management Order (TMO) under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 makes idling a strict civil traffic contravention. However, the report indicates that the current approach prioritises engagement. Data shows that over 85% of vehicles observed already had their engines switched off. Of the remaining drivers, 95.7% moved on or switched off their engines when approached by an officer.
Officers noted that the personal interaction between CEOs and drivers is key to resolving the issue, often resulting in the vehicle being driven away or the engine being switched off, thus avoiding the need for PCNs. This approach is seen as more effective than solely relying on enforcement.
However, officers also noted several circumstances where idling may be permitted or understandable. These include vehicles stationary due to traffic, engines being run to trace and rectify a defect, or when machinery on a vehicle requires the engine to be running. On cold days, particularly at taxi ranks or for elderly drivers, engines may be run for warmth, and defrosting windscreens in very cold weather is also considered a mitigating circumstance. The supplied passages state that mitigating circumstances for engine idling include running an engine on a cold day at a taxi rank, for an elderly driver to keep warm, or to defrost a windscreen.